Having used both versions of Autumn Falls' Cream extensively, I vastly prefer the Birthday Cake Edition. I think this is what the original probably should have been, as I personally find the suction of the original to be a bit excessive. To me, the earlier version feels like a rough blowjob from someone inexperienced. The Birthday Cake Edition, by contrast, is significantly more forgiving, and really does feel much more like a blissful sexual experience with a nubile woman, where you can feel all of the warm, wet contours of her tight vagina contracting around your erect member. This is probably my favorite fleshlight overall (or perhaps tied with Nikki Benz' Birthday MVP; I can't pick just one), as the tightness and realism are perfect for my taste. For reference, I prefer less rough, more realistic-feeling fleshlights for prolonged edging sessions. This one is even better than Luna Star's Birthday Cake Edition Glimmer, which already blew my mind, and which I also prefer to the original.